2,664 Likes, 162 Comments - Dylan Shiel (@dylanshiel) on Instagram: “” 280 Posts - See Instagram photos and videos from ‘dylanshiel’ hashtag And he received no punishment. Anything more would have been overkill (it is a contact sport after all). 12.3k Followers, 1,027 Following, 46 Posts - See Instagram photos and videos from Dylan Clarke (@dylannclarkee) Accidental or not a free should have been awarded and Cotchin should have copped a fine. October 30, 2017 And yeah, I get that concussions may happen because of sport and that's not the point I'm trying to make. Superstars should be treated as harshly/leniently as a reserve with a handful of games. A lot of @zacharymerrett07 about this. To assign a user flair to yourself, expand the 'Community Options' drop-down menu below, and click on the pencil icon. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Shiel has a right to be upset I think. It has failed us with its lack of consistency. Probably that concussion he suffered from the Crotchin hit causing him to not think through his actions. 149w Reply. It's what we should be encouraging players to do for their long term health. Cotchin's action (which would have resulted in a fine or suspension during the season) costed GWS one of their best players and possibly a grand final berth. Hopefully creates a good rivalry between these two clubs going forward. AFL: The home of Australian football on Reddit, including the Australian Football League, and all other aspects of the game. 100% agree. On one hand, some people think it was the right call. Midnight workouts. And he received no punishment. I think the idea of a "glass jaw" is something relevant to the conversation around these sort of incidents. 4,109 Likes, 21 Comments - Dylan Shiel (@dylanshiel) on Instagram: “Thank you 2019... ready for 2020!” By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Press J to jump to the feed. Cotch went low and hard at the man, making head high contact. It's a really complex and divisive issue. Only question is what contrived label they would apply to this rivalry? #mambamentality” On the other, some people think it it's the wrong call. Yeah that's pretty shitty, it sounds like Shiel did his due diligence and let the doctors know he was experiencing pretty clear symptoms of concussion. They followed the rules written out exactly. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. The commentators could really get behind that. Another instance were player profile and external circumstances come into play where it shouldn't. 36.5k Followers, 75 Following, 51 Posts - See Instagram photos and videos from Dylan Shiel (@dylanshiel) Did you write Carlton's statement regarding marriage equality? I don't think it was the right call, but I'm happy that it was the decision that was made. Shiel has a right to be upset I think. They got this call right, it's all the others that were wrong. If Danger wasn't such a tank and got KTFO from the Sloane hit, how different would the conversation be to the current "just two blokes going hard", and if Shiel wasn't concussed from the Cotchin collision, we'd be applauding a hard contest. I would be pretty salty, even if you think he shouldn't have been suspended that is a free kick every day of the week. Yeah you don't get to man up and make concussions vanish into the wind.. That isn't how brains work. If Cotchin wasn't already on two strikes, that hit is 100% a fine. I can't understand how people put off injury so nonchalantly. Something from the Twitter comments that actually upsets me is this derogative notion of a "Glass jaw" and that Shiels concussion was a result of him being soft. Hope your having a great time Dylan x. I have everything against the credibility of the AFL and the MRP system. Dylan Shiel will miss two matches for rough conduct over the bump that floored North Melbourne’s Curtis Taylor after the Essendon star was unsuccessful in appealing … This is pretty strange to see, don't often see players come after each other like this. But don't victim blame, what the hell? No reward for the guy with his head over the pill, but we reward people who drop the knees and lean into the tackler. 4,266 Likes, 42 Comments - Dylan Shiel (@dylanshiel) on Instagram: “3am wake ups. Agreed, but I hope when the fix it, they do it in a way that sees less players suspended for minor things rather than more. Cotchin's action (which would have resulted in a fine or suspension during the season) costed GWS one of their best players and possibly a grand final berth. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast.

Movies Like Berlin Syndrome, Split Color Hoodie Wholesale, Topperlearning Class 7 History, Pickman's Model Audiobook, How To Catch A Football With One Hand, Weak And Powerless Meaning,